Blog Layout

Is knowledge really power in coaching?

Emilia Rolewicz • Feb 02, 2023

“Sometimes our ego takes over

and we cease to be curious”

In this blog post we review the conversation between CebAI and former Olympic coach and England Rugby's Head of Performance, Nigel Redman. Nigel explains why experience and knowledge are not enough to coach for peak performance; there is something much more important required.

NIgel Redman on stage at the CebAI conference, he is a middle aged clean shaven man with a shaved head

What is a swimmer without water? That is the question that taxed swim coaches during lockdown. How can aquatic athletes perfect their butterfly, crawl or tumble turns when all the pools are closed?


Nigel Redman, rugby legend and former Olympic GB swim team coach, saw the catastrophic closing of training pools not as a disaster, but as an excellent opportunity to prove a theory.


At CebAI’s annual CreAtIve Comm conference, Nigel took to the stage to talk to CebAI Director, Professor Neil Maiden, about why keeping curious and creative is the key to unlocking brilliant coaching.

“KNOWLEDGE

 CAN BE

THE BIGGEST

INHIBITOR

OF GROWTH”

Nigel reflected on his years of coaching at England Rugby, as well as with the GB Olympic swimming team at Rio and Tokyo: “Although people say knowledge is power, my experience says knowledge can be the biggest inhibitor of growth.”


It seems crazy to think that the knowledge a coach, let alone an Olympic level coach, has built up over the years could be somehow limiting.  But when an unfamiliar problem presents itself at a crucial moment, the most effective solution can be to look outside of what is already known.

“In a lot of cases, once people feel they have the answer, they stop being curious” Nigel explains.


When working with the GB Olympic swimming team, he recalled a time when an athlete swam seven seconds second slower than they had in the British trials.


The swim coach had ticked off all the standard physical coaching boxes and looked at the problem from a technical, a tactical and a physical perspective.

Swimmer in the pool, head down stretching forward in a front crawl

The coach had “never realised how much the London Olympics was playing on [the swimmer’s] mentality” Nigel says, referring to the coach's blindspot, the psychological impact on performance.


Nigel often sees this lack of broad-ranging exploratory thinking in coaching. “Sometimes in a bid to gain credibility, our ego takes over and we cease to be curious” he says.

Nigel’s passion now is to get members of a team to see the value of the bigger picture and brainstorm outside of their usual thinking patterns. He actively works to inspire a more curious and creative approach.

BREAKING WITH TRADITIONAL WAYS OF THINKING

Coaching is a fairly rigid craft, often entrenched in tradition and expectations, as Nigel found out.


Known for his rugby background, when Nigel began working with the GB swim team, he was asked "how did you maintain credibility in a sport that you know nothing about?".

“You’re right, I don’t know anything about swimming.” Nigel replied. “So why don’t you tell me what you know about swimming?”


Nigel Redman looking directly at the camera, he is a middle aged man with a shaved head, wearing a sports top

Nigel noticed that the biggest barriers weren’t related to the technicalities of swimming, but to broader, all-encompassing soft skill areas like communication and mindset.


He set out to prove to his doubters that swimming expertise wasn’t the most important instrument in overcoming challenges.


Because coaches tend to rely so much on past experience and habit to inform present problem solving, new and unexpected conditions can be overwhelming. COVID became a huge barrier for many coaches and athletes. Swimming pools were shut down, and coaches complained there was no training that could be effectively achieved under this constraint.

YOU DON'T NEED TO GET WET TO GET FIT

Two women in a gym doing one arm press-ups

Nigel took a different stance: “You don’t need to get wet to get fit” he told his team.


Forced to adapt to new conditions, the swimmers were encouraged to resort to running and other activities that didn’t require their usual training facilities.


For Nigel this was a victory, as he had been a proponent of athletes training outside of their sport for years prior.


He worked around the limitation to demonstrate that no water did not mean no training.

Using a creative problem solving technique called Constraint Removal, Nigel demonstrated that keeping an open mind, remaining curious to exploring other ideas, can overcome what, on the surface, seemed to be a disaster.

Watch the full discussion to find out more

23 Apr, 2024
Where can coaches turn to for help when they're out of time, out of colleagues, and out of ideas? THE CHALLENGES OF COACHING A 2020 study by Leeds Beckett University identified 17 main categories coaches’ problems fall into. Problems with player-coach interaction, coaching knowledge and skills, and the coaching workforce were in the top 4. In terms of support networks, the research found that coaches would look “closest to home: to themselves, their family/friends” [1], instead of branching out to find alternatives. These factors can make sports coaching an isolating and challenging environment to innovate in. This case study explores how using an AI tool, Sport Sparks to generate ideas and develop solutions, can be a beneficial ‘coach in your pocket’ tech tool - a source of both knowledge and support.
The English cricket team celebrating
by Emilia Rolewicz 03 Aug, 2023
In this blog post we look at the new 'Bazball' phenomenon in cricket and how this creative approach has revolutionised the English team. Bazball has reinvigorated English cricket with creativity and captured the imagination of the fans, which was on full display at the 2023 Ashes. The final test of the Ashes series ended in another England win over their old rivals Australia, and tie the series. Only bad weather in Manchester denied the revived England team yet another series win. Bazball is the new, exciting cricket strategy on the pitch – an approach favouring aggression and fearlessness – and a great example of transformational creativity. Margaret Boden, Research Professor of Cognitive Science and creative theory pioneer, defines this type of creativity as: “a transformation of the search space so new kinds of ideas can be generated.” Coach Brendon McCullum promised just that when he joined the England team in 2022, wanting to strip away the timid English approach to cricket and describing the team as “guys who are maybe just a little bit stuck by the fear of failure rather than the possibility of success.” He also added: “It's just allowing the guys to be able to make good decisions because they're in a clear frame of mind and a positive environment.” The focus on psychological safety and a positive mindset paved the way for the English team to try a riskier form of play with more confidence.
Carlos Alcaraz at Wimbledon 2023
17 Jul, 2023
No one really thought that a 20 year old - even one as physically strong as Alcaraz - would have the psychological chops to smash Djokovic. At this level of elite sports, where athleticism is pretty equal, winning and losing boils down to mindset more than muscle. In this blog we breakdown how Alcaraz has developed a number of creative problem solving practices that enable him to conquer the one of the world's most successful players, a tennis Terminator, undefeated at Wimbledon in decade.
John Curry, figure skater
by Emilia Rolewicz 18 Apr, 2023
"I always wanted to be able to present skating in a way I had not seen before."
10 Mar, 2023
England captain Leah Williamson described Head Coach Sarina Wiegman as the "missing ingredient." In this blog post we explore the creative strategies Head Coach Sarina Wiegman introduced to the Women's England Football team, which lead to their unmatched performance and sterling victory at the Euros 2022.
Emma Raducanu C. Raducanu
by Sam Steele, Professor Neil Maiden 24 Aug, 2022
Raducanu's risky strategy is  challenging the coaching status quo In this blog post we consider the volatile Raducanu coaching strategy that has been described by commentators as wild, risky and downright trigger-happy. We discuss coaching, the creative process and consider if the Raducanu approach is cutting edge creative or simply cut-throat crazy?
basketball player jumping high to make a hoop
by Sam Steele 08 Aug, 2022
The Growth Triple Play
A voyager rocket, white hot fuel tanks blasting through the atmosphere into space
by Sam Steele 05 Aug, 2022
Get more out of your research
fireworks display at night
by Sam Steele 05 Aug, 2022
There's no such thing as too many ideas
a person jumping for joy on a beach, facing the sea at sunset, birds gliding in the sky
by Sam Steele 05 Aug, 2022
Why the problem is the most important part...
More posts
Share by: